Just my imagination

[The Italian]

Penelope: "Do you REALLY said that you can beat me?"
Scarlett: "No....I said I can kick your ass anytime"

And then this two lovely ladies go at it in a scratching, slapping, clothes ripping, breast mauling, old fashioned catfight

[rasta808]

i would love to see this fight.

[kimval]

yes, i agree. it's fast and furious, but not long as Penny is just too, too much and overwhelms the younger, busty blonde. hope someone will write the story, so we will all know the truth

[billblah]

Penelope vs Scarlett . Very hot fight? both girls with big breast, looks not very tough. Penelope taller, Scarlett younger. The Mediterranean brunette against the northern blonde. I prefer Scarlett, because looks sexier but for the fight I think that the Spanish girl has the upper hand. Scarlett looks so delicate and Penelope has the wild latin spirit?.

And a poll from catfight forum about this fight?
Penelope Cruz vs. Scarlett Johansson

[MindCastle]

This would be a great match-up. According to IMDB, Penelope is 5'4 1/2 and Scarlett is 5'4 1/4. Celebrity Sleuth has Penelope @34C-25-36, 119 lbs. and Scarlett @34D-22-35, 113 lbs. (At the time they filmed "Vicky, Christina, Barcelona.)

Since neither gal has an referenced martial arts experience nor appear to be particularly athletic, this would come down to a good old hairpulling catfight. Considering the fact that they had a lesbian encounter in the movie "Vicky, Christina Barcelona" (much to the dismay of Selma Hayek), I believe that this battle would be best fought in bed.

Although Scarlett is 10 year's Penelope's junior, I believe Penelope would remain very competitive. She was a dancer most of her life and still apparently does dance routines (Ballerina) today. I recently saw her in the movie 'Nine' and I must say that I was very impressed with her body and especially her legs. If she ever got them around Scarlett's 22" waist, it would be lights out for Scarlett. On the mat, the advantage would go to Scarlett; on the bed, the advantage would definitely go to Penelope.