Just came from "Charley and the choco factory"

[Moviemaniac4]

I still preffer the original with Gene Wilder. My kid love it, and some of the music was catchy and updated, but it wasnt the same.....

[Joranthalus]

wasn't supposed to be the same [img]smile.gif[/img]

I like them both, though i'd love to see Tim's version get a tighter edit...

[BigC]

I'm with the original one all the way.

[DemonsAngel]

i liked them both.... i think my kids like the new one better. it's cool having them be different [img]graemlins/thumbs_up.gif[/img]

[chaserfan]

I'll rent it when it comes out, but I cant imagine it can be better than the first.