I might as well throw in my two cents (three in Canada)...
I couldn't care less about awards shows or the awards themselves. That said, in my opinion Walk The Line deserves whatever credit anyone wants to give it simply because they didn't fuck the story up as badly as I was sure they would.
As I see it Reese Withers poon, while far from spot-on, did a decent job of portraying JCC all things considered. I, like the King Himself, went into it having every reason in the world to believe she would singlehandedly destroy the movie but left thinking she did a pretty good job.
(Never saw Ray, not planning to... not particularly a Ray Charles fan and can't stand Jamie Foxx for even 10 seconds)
Bookmarks