Re: Myabe a DUH! Question for Audio & Acoustic Engineers
Quote:
Originally Posted by
417 - Alnico
If I have a 417, with a 414 Open mesh paper dome on it and the back or bottom of the Ceramic frame; magnet also has a the round Vent Hole...If both top and bottom of the speaker are open, will that adversely effect the sound and low end frequencies?
If I have a 417, with a 414 Open mesh paper dome on it and the back or bottom of the Ceramic frame; magnet also has a the round Vent Hole...If both top and bottom of the speaker are open, will that adversely effect the sound and low end frequencies?
Re: Question for Audio & Acoustic Engineers
Can't comment about the metal plate, but the 414's VC is vented through the DC while the 417's vented out the rear, so if a vented DC is used on a 417, this then creates a semi-aperiodic vent that should affect both its 'tone' and LF performance, so would require a sealed cab of 'x' net Vb that would have to be arrived at empirically for best reflex performance. If used in an open back MI cab, then you'd just have to try it to see if it sounded 'good enough' to you.
Bottom line, it's probably best to plug up the rear vent when using a vented DC.
GM
Re: Question for Audio & Acoustic Engineers
Re: Question for Audio & Acoustic Engineers
Quote:
Originally Posted by
GM
Can't comment about the metal plate, but the 414's VC is vented through the DC while the 417's vented out the rear, so if a vented DC is used on a 417, this then creates a semi-aperiodic vent that should affect both its 'tone' and LF performance, so would require a sealed cab of 'x' net Vb that would have to be arrived at empirically for best reflex performance. If used in an open back MI cab, then you'd just have to try it to see if it sounded 'good enough' to you.
Bottom line, it's probably best to plug up the rear vent when using a vented DC.
GM
Not to disagree at all, just a question...
Are you thinking 421? The 417 has the same mag as 414 AFAIK. The 417 has no vent in back and the aluminum dome....
But yes, as you say, vent one or the other way but not both.
Re: Question for Audio & Acoustic Engineers
Truth be told, I don't remember, just responded to what he wrote, so if he's wrong, I'm wrong. Don't recall having any hands on experience with ceramic 414s and the vast majority of my MI experience is with the 421 series, so what he wrote seemed reasonable...........
I'm surprised that any MI driver would be ventless though. I wouldn't think an aluminum DC would be enough.
GM
Re: Question for Audio & Acoustic Engineers
Actually I should expand since what I said was only true of Alnico, but AFAIK all 417 are Alnico.
The late 414 was ceramic, and had a metal plate inside to block the rear vent. That way it could use the standard 414 kit. Must be what he is referring to.
http://www.lansingheritage.org/image...-mi/page04.jpg
Don't think the 418 had a rear vent either. Was also Alnico/aluminum dome
Re: Question for Audio & Acoustic Engineers
Quote:
Originally Posted by
GM
I'm surprised that any MI driver would be ventless though. I wouldn't think an aluminum DC would be enough.
Please pardon my ignorance but was there a functional reason in using an aluminum dust cap?
Did it significantly enhance heat dissipation?
I kind of thought some marketing guy requested them just to draw attention to the drivers on stage.
Re: Myabe a DUH! Question for Audio & Acoustic Engineers
Quote:
Originally Posted by
417 - Alnico
If I have a 417, with a 414 Open mesh paper dome on it and the back or bottom of the Ceramic frame; magnet also has a the round Vent Hole...If both top and bottom of the speaker are open, will that adversely effect the sound and low end frequencies?
414 open dome, on a 417 kit, in a 12'' vented frame.
Thanks OG.
Some later 12"Creamics had vent Holes in the bottom;
maybe not older ones.
I have two sets, that are not white framed, 1987ish.
917 frames that came with 414's.
I have mentioned this many times without any confirmation, that the later, dark Gray framed Ferrite frames were used for the remaining available 12' spaeker made.
http://www.lansingheritage.org/image...hort/page4.jpg