Well... It's a tough one, but for attitude and charisma if not vocal capacity it has to be Taime!
Well... It's a tough one, but for attitude and charisma if not vocal capacity it has to be Taime!
Vocal ability - Axl
Glaminess - Axl in the early days
Sleaziness - Taime
Attitude - Axl is an asshole, Taime is cool but a bit reclusive
Image - nowadays Taime all the way, poor Axl has those hair plugs
Longevity - Taime
Respect today - Taime
F***ing brilliant reply - spot on I agree 100%
[img]tongue.gif[/img] The one catogery you missed name...
Axl Rose translates as A supporting shaft or member on or with which a wheel or a set of wheels revolves/girly flower
Taime Downe is just the sleaziest innuendo filled name ever
Taime wins this one hands down NUFF SAID [img]wink.gif[/img]
Finally an easy one LOL
TAIME all the way! I love both bands and think I have also joined a discussion here where I fought for GNR... but that was on another topic.
Axl's voice is annoying and not particularily good. On his best nights he's just a bit annoying, but on not so good ones he's so horrible it's impossible to watch a whole gig.
Taime has more "bad voice" days than Axl, but when your style and attitude is to sing like an Alleycat it's not so important.
Taime is one of my all time favourite voices in rock.
Taime for me.
Hey Kriss have ya put yourself on the map yet?
Taime all the way. Axl is a pox on humanity and he ruined what may have been a really good band. Well, IMO. GnR started good, then he opened his mouth and it all went to shit.
I'm just glad the heading says 'vocalist', and not singers, lol.
Taime.. Axl's voice irritated me for the longest time, until I got used to it and grew to like it, but I still prefer the tracks where he doesn't go all out screechy.
Both are cool but, Taime wins.
I'll have to go with Taime....although Taime's vocals after a few songs...starts to annoy me.
As for Axl, I've said it before but I'll say it again...I always thought he sang like a sick flea infested alleycat with diareah. [img]wink.gif[/img]
Taime easily . Axl is a twat!!
I was gonna put myself on the map, but I recently cut my long hair and now I look too...well...ordinary! I don't look glam - I have short hair! When it grows I'll add a pic!
Taime all the way!
Axl - http://forums.maxima.org/images/smilies/loser.gif Looooooser!
BOTH OR TAIME!!!
Axl best singer. Axl best dickhead.
They were both great,
I got to give it Axl for becoming the biggest rock star on the planet for awhile...
but If you are talking modern day it would be
Mr. Tamie Downe....
Taime Downe......No question about it Taime could also hold Axl down and make him eat poop....
How did Axl possibly ruin the band,he was dealing with major junkies,just because he wanted to make his band succeed he had to be tough but that doesn't make make an a**hole,whatever you say his voice is unmistakeable like or not,there is no comparison with Taime,just as good,in a different way.Axl will always be GnR.FACT.
TAIME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
love that sleazy rawk.
At Rock City in Oct 1987 it was Taime all the way. Axl was an asshole.
ok just like my vote for the o-punks and g-punks - I will post a vote for both Taime and Axl because they're both unique and great in their own way.
<font size="4" face="Arial">Not if you saw Taime when he fronted Bondage Boys! Did you ever see him then! Man I wish I still had the pictures ha ha!Quote:
Originally posted by Hairglamfan:
Glaminess - Axl in the early days