Re: If there were a playoff
Sometimes the BCS gets it right but I would rather see a playoff system in college football!
What do you all think about it?
Re: If there were a playoff
[ QUOTE ]
Sometimes the BCS gets it right but I would rather see a playoff system in college football!
What do you all think about it?
[/ QUOTE ]
BCS is never right. The only right way is a playoff.
Re: If there were a playoff
It's about money.
But i agree every one else from NAIA to Div. 1 AA has a playoff system that seems to work.
Re: If there were a playoff
if NCAA goes to playoff then everyone will complain about why the #4 got in and not #5 or #8 & not #9...etc
Re: If there were a playoff
Maybe the guy on ESPN I was listening to had it right: Add just one game, have the #1 draw a bye and watch #2 and #3 go at it, playing the winner the following week-not perfect, but a simple, sensible improvement IMO. I think with the parity, and evolution of college football over the last decade or so, we'll never have to worry about FOUR unbeatens, and somebody being "left out". If you have a loss, you really have no right to gripe (unless you get jumped by another 1-loss team).
Re: If there were a playoff
There is a playoff and/or tournament in every division and sport except for Div 1 Football.
They say it can't be done but every other sport and Div seem to be able to do it.
They talk about Travel being expensive...the NCAA Basketball tournament and the travel those teams do couldn't be much worse.
Until these people decided to not be greedy for money. A playoff would raise tons of money by the way ... only thing is the Universities would not be getting the big pay day!
Until it is settled on the field, the BCS will never get it right!
Re: If there were a playoff
[ QUOTE ]
the NCAA Basketball tournament and the travel those teams do couldn't be much worse.
[/ QUOTE ]
Could be a little worse traveling with nearly 100 versus 20.
Why can't the playoff games be the bowl games, forget about the conference tie-ins and play crowds won't be a problem these days the way people travel.
Re: If there were a playoff
[ QUOTE ]
Why can't the playoff games be the bowl games
[/ QUOTE ]
I agree .. they could be!
Orange - 15.5 million
Rose - 15.5 million
Fiesta -15.5 million
Sugar - 15.5 million
Capital One - 4.25 million
Music City - 3.2 million
Cotton - 3 million
Outback - 3 million
Chic-fila - 2.825 million
Gator - 2.5 million
Alamo - 2.25 million
Holiday - 2.2 million
Champs Sports - 2.2 million
Shoot that's the top 13 bowl games right there. Move the dates around and get the top 8 teams and have a playoff!
In the 1st Round play the top four bowls (ROSE, ORANGE, SUGAR. FEISTA) and reward the teams for making the playoffs! All 8 teams would get the 15.5 million dollar pay out per bowl!
The 2nd Round you have the final four and play 2 games. Play the Cotton Bowl and the OutBack Bowl and both those teams would get the 3 million pay out per game!
For the championship game play the BCS CHAMPIONSHIP GAME which is worth another 15.5 million in pay out.
NOW LOOK AT THE POSSIBLITY OF MONEY A TEAM COULD EARN....IF THEY MADE THE PLAYOFFS!
WIN OR LOSE all 8 teams would make 7.75 million the 1st Round.
WIN OR LOSE in the FINAL FOUR... all 4 teams have made 9.25 million combined in 2 Rounds.
If you make it to the National Championship game in this format WIN OR LOSE both teams will make 17 million TOTAL per team in 3 Rounds of football.
Only the winner takes home that nice
WATERFORD CRYSTAL FOOTBALL
http://technique.library.gatech.edu/...09-28-29-1.jpg
AND GET THE RINGS!
THIS WOULD BE VERY MOTIVATING I WOULD THINK TO GET YOUR TEAM IN THE PLAYOFFS EVERY YEAR!
There are way too many bowl games that reward for mediocrity. Let's do away with all these games and settle this on the field.
To the other teams that don't make the playoffs...well, it's time to hit the gym and practice field and get ready for next year!
Re: If there were a playoff
Do away with the bowl system, which will never happen because of the $$.
Either have a playoff just like D-1 or forget about it.
Re: If there were a playoff
[ QUOTE ]
Do away with the bowl system, which will never happen because of the $$.
Either have a playoff just like D-1 or forget about it.
[/ QUOTE ]
You are not doing away with the bowl games in this format!
And you are not rewarding for mediocre seasons either!
We have too many bowls that are a waste of time.
I came up with this format because all you hear is the Presidents of these Universities don't wanna give up the money they could earn. Well if their team made it in the playoffs in this format they would make plenty of cash!
Re: If there were a playoff
Do away with the bowl games or have a playoff.
No. Try not. Do... or do not. There is no try.
To institute a playoff and 'keep' the bowl system is asinine.
Re: If there were a playoff
[ QUOTE ]
Do away with the bowl games or have a playoff.
No. Try not. Do... or do not. There is no try.
To institute a playoff and 'keep' the bowl system is asinine.
[/ QUOTE ]
I AGREE WITH THAT AS WELL!
I was just trying to make everyone (UNVERSITY PRESIDENTS [img]/LDPforum/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/wink.gif[/img]) happy!
BOWLS SMOWLS! IMO!! haha
Would much rather see a playoff to settle this!
Its going to happen when we have 3 undefeated teams at the end of the year and the BCS will be screwed I think!
PAC -10
BIG 12
BIG 10
ACC
3 of these 4 conferences IMO will be undfeated at some point at the end of a year and screw the BCS.
Just my opinion...I leave the SEC out cas they beat each other up and will always have a 1 loss team! haha
Re: If there were a playoff
[ QUOTE ]
Its going to happen when we have 3 undefeated teams at the end of the year and the BCS will be screwed I think!
[/ QUOTE ]
That already happened with Auburn missing out. I find myself mowe interested in D1AA than D1A this year. Lets go Montana Grizzlies!
Re: If there were a playoff
WHATS WRONG WITH YOU!?
APPY STATE! WHY MONTANA!?
LOL
APPY STATE PLAYS YOUNGSTOWN THIS WEEKEND AT APPY!
Re: If there were a playoff
I dont like any team from NC. I had to edit cause I said TN. [img]/LDPforum/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/wall.gif[/img] I dont like teams from TN or NC. [img]/LDPforum/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/grin.gif[/img] [img]/LDPforum/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/tongue.gif[/img]
Re: If there were a playoff
[ QUOTE ]
I dont like any team from TN. [img]/LDPforum/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/tongue.gif[/img]
[/ QUOTE ]
hahaha
They are in Boone, North Carolina just over the mountain! haha
TN school!? hahaha
NOW THAT WAS FUNNY!
Re: If there were a playoff
[ QUOTE ]
I dont like any team from NC. I had to edit cause I said TN. [img]/LDPforum/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/wall.gif[/img] I dont like teams from TN or NC. [img]/LDPforum/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/grin.gif[/img] [img]/LDPforum/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/tongue.gif[/img]
[/ QUOTE ]
How can you not root for either JMU or Appy State? [img]/LDPforum/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/wall.gif[/img]
Re: If there were a playoff
Besides ASU has already beaten Montana last week 38-17! haha
Re: If there were a playoff
[ QUOTE ]
Besides ASU has already beaten Montana last week 38-17! haha
[/ QUOTE ]
Next year baby! [img]/LDPforum/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/grin.gif[/img] And I do pull for JMU first but they went out in the first round.hahaha! [img]/LDPforum/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/grin.gif[/img]
What do the matchups look like coming up this week besides Appy and Youngstown? The way Appy is looking though there is no doubt in my mind they will be back to back National Champs. With them being so close I wonder why Times News dont write much about them?
Re: If there were a playoff
(12-1)Montana @ (12-1)Massachusetts
Friday @ 7:30pm
Appy beat Montana State last week and not Montana!
By bad! haha
(11-2) Youngstown State @ (12-1) Appalachian State
1st Round started on Nov. 25th and the Title game in next weekend December 15th @ 8pm in Chattanooga, TN.
HOW HARD IS THIS FOR THE BIGGER SCHOOLS TO DO!
Here is a look a the Bracket for this playoff:
http://www.ncaasports.com/football/m...6_dyn/2006/FCS
Re: If there were a playoff
I didnt think Montana was beat yet. I strongly beleive the bigger scholls will go to somewhat of a playoff in the next 10 to 20 years. Just need to see some people in the BCS that is pro playoff. It will happen. Probably start as a 4 team playoff.
Re: If there were a playoff
Here's the BCS 2006 playoffs:
ESPN-ABC sets the brackets:
# 1 Ohio State VS. # 4 Auburn, All Big Ten officials.
Ohio State wins 24-7, Auburn is flagged for 200 yards.
# 2 Florida VS. # 3 Michigan, All Big Ten officials.
Michigan wins 31-24, Florida is flagged for 175 yards.
Title game at the Rose Bowl: Ohio State 31 Michigan 28 ESPN-ABC wins.
The Nationial Championship game is renamed the ESPN-ABC-Keith Jackson (Whoa Nellie)Super Attraction. [img]/LDPforum/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/wall.gif[/img]