Printable View
Its been weird this year...
its about all you can say, welcome opinions to why no ones dominateing...
as you may of heard though....toby gerheart looks to be around 2nd on the list...has a white running back ever won the heisman?? if not do you think he would get recognizition for being the first to do so? what about his chances of playing running back in the NFL? do you think its possible?
gerhart mancrush obviously
Saw this on something the other day...last one was John Cappelletti in like 73. He played for Penn State
there have been several white RB's to win the Heisman.
my vote would go to Ingram, but itll go to McCoy
not if bama wins NC
The Heisman is awarded before the NC game. It's like the weekend after conference championships.Quote:
Originally Posted by DJP
haha how foolish, id say if texas and bama both take care of bussiness ingram gets the edge
wont happen
bama has never had a player win the heisman, and when mcfadden lost it to tebow, i knew no SEC RB ever will again
I don't think there will be any question, the logical choice is tim tebow. He should have won it last year and made this year the third heisman for him.
you gotta be kidding me
out of the top 5 heisman candidates, tebow would be the least deserving.
he does not have the stats to win it this year, if he does, itll be twice since he robbed another SEC RB two years ago, McFadden.
Why would you give it to Tebow raider75? His stats? His team? Why? Why should Tebow win? Please explain
and to suggest Tebow should have won three straight is absolutely ludicrous
Colt McCoy is your Heisman winner. Whether anyone thinks he deserves it or not, its a done deal. No bout a doubt it.
I think the Heisman should be for seniors only. The year Tebow won, I think he snubbed McFadden.
Wouldn't mind seeing Stanfords running back get it... he's a beast
If you made it for seniors only most of the time the best player would never get it, well best player that ESPN likes haha...but most of the stars are gonna leave early
Quote:
Originally Posted by Biggin
Army had 2 white RBs win Heisman in Doc Blanchard and Glenn Davis
remember the year it was Peyton Manning vs Charles Woodson. all the ESPN guys kept saying "the Heisman isn't a career award, it is what you've done for that year". Yet, in the next year or two one of the RB's was up for it and all they could say was that "no running back that has ever rushed for such-n-such many yards over their career has never NOT won the Heisman." so one year when the didn't want Manning to get it, they state it isn't a career award but when a RB that rushed for over so many yards in his career is up for it he is a shoe-in because of what he did over his career.Quote:
Originally Posted by VolDude