Printable View
A survey of over 40'000 people voted Definitely -Maybe the best Uk album ever made over Sgt Peppers in 2nd. OK computer by Radiohead 3rd, and what's the Story-Morning Glory in 4th.
Interesting
<font color="#FF0099" size="1">[ June 01, 2006 01:52 PM: Message edited by: Fleagle the Guitarist ]</font>
Sgt Peppers is not the best Beatles album and it might not be better than Definatley maybe, but there is no doubt it was very important in the development of pop music.
H
Hell, I saw that Top 10 in the list, and none of those friggin' albums would even land in my personal Top 100.
IMHO i think What's the Story Morning Glory is a better album then Definitely Maybe ....
.... and i hate the Beatles so nothing by them would ever land in my top 10
<font size="4" face="Arial">Thank God somebody in this world still says that. I like them, but I am soooo fucking sick of them STILL being the "Greatest Band Ever" and all that bullshit. I am so sick of the bands that you are supposed to like. I shocked people by my claim that the best thing Black Sabbath ever did was WITHOUT Ozzy and was in fact Mob Rules and that Ozzy's best material was with Randy and NOT Iommi. Seriously, why do we all have to swing by the nuts of what is supposed to be great? Ozzy era Sab was boring drudge and The Beatles, whilst setting many standards, are not beyond passing for greatness. I would rather spend days listening to Hanoi Rocks than listening to The Beatles, and Hanoi isn't even my favorite band (though I have completely given up on having a "favorite band" anymore).Quote:
Originally posted by creeper2:
.... and i hate the Beatles so nothing by them would ever land in my top 10
I'm not terribly into Oasis nor the Beatles. Have a couple of records from each and listen to them once every decade maybe.
I can't remember the titles of the Oasis albums, but I have the 3 first ones and think they just got better.
The first one seemed a bit long and boring. Not a lot going on in the songs and most of them are waaaaayyyyy too long. Some cool ones though, btu not an album I cherish at all. What's The Story (isn't that the second one?) was a bit better, but still also a bit boring.
The third one is the one I thought was best. It also had it's long songs, but generally the quality of the songs on that album is a lot better than on the 2 first ones.
I preffer the Beatles when they do pop/rock... the later acid era is not my thing at all. Sgt. Pepper has some cool songs, but way too much bullshit in my oppinion. A Day In The Life could have been a brilliant song but "Hey, let's fuck it up with a looooooong middle part that means nothing and isn't really clever, just to have it there" LOL
Well, just my 2 cents as usual
See, and I think the middle part (McCartney's part) is the best part of that song. [img]biggrin.gif[/img]
Hmmmm.... The noise part, Carl?
That's wierd.... or maybe not. It's just a matter of taste I suppose, but I thought I went with a safe bet in dissing that. Seems not LOL
Aren't they the same band?.....
<font size="4" face="Arial">Do you mean the noise leading into the McCartney 30's style thing that comes about in the middle? Of the actual McCartney bit part of the song?Quote:
Originally posted by chrisdamien:
Hmmmm.... The noise part, Carl?
That's wierd.... or maybe not. It's just a matter of taste I suppose, but I thought I went with a safe bet in dissing that. Seems not LOL
"Woke up got out of bed............."
That bit
H
I mean the noise part that seems to last forever... I never understood that
40,000 30something middle class, Q magazine-
bothering white blokes voted Oasis above the
Beatles. Nowt more, nowt less.
D.
<font size="4" face="Arial">Do you mean the noise leading into the McCartney 30's style thing that comes about in the middle? Of the actual McCartney bit part of the song?</font><hr /></blockquote><font size="4" face="Arial">I believe that's the Ringo-sung part, right?Quote:
Originally posted by Carl I.:
</font><blockquote><font size="1" face="Arial">quote:</font><hr /><font size="4" face="Arial">Originally posted by chrisdamien:
Hmmmm.... The noise part, Carl?
That's wierd.... or maybe not. It's just a matter of taste I suppose, but I thought I went with a safe bet in dissing that. Seems not LOL
I like What's the Story Morning Glory, personally. Great cd.
Is that Ringo??? Nah, I could swear that is Paul. They only gave Ringo one song on that album. I could swear that it's Paul. Time for some research...
<font size="4" face="Arial">I might totally be wrong. Just reminded me of him a bit. I guess that if it was up to me, I'd only give Ringo one song per album. [img]smile.gif[/img] Great song, btw, broken up by that crappy interlude. Written from the headlines on a paper, from what I understand.Quote:
Originally posted by Carl I.:
Is that Ringo??? Nah, I could swear that is Paul. They only gave Ringo one song on that album. I could swear that it's Paul. Time for some research...
I also think Whats the Story is a better album than Definitely Maybe. I think both of them are better than Sgt Peppers. I think neither of them come close to Beatles for Sale or The White Album.
Anyone who cannot see the aesthetic beauty or the pure melodic genius of the Beatles has been to the surgeon and had a head transplant with an Alsation dog. I wouldnt want to listen to them every day, for sure, but I wouldn't want to drink a bottle of Rothchild 72 every day either, regardless of how fine it is.
Lots of cars go as fast as a Ferrari 420, but they are NOT Ferrari's, and no amount of horsepower or styling will ever make them so.
Im sure you see my point here.
Someone fell out of the simile tree this morning.
Shut up and get editing!
<font size="4" face="Arial">hey, are you trying to imply that an Alsatian Dog has better taste in music then a human? that's really not nice.Quote:
Originally posted by Fleagle the Guitarist:
Anyone who cannot see the aesthetic beauty or the pure melodic genius of the Beatles has been to the surgeon and had a head transplant with an Alsation dog.
<font size="4" face="Arial">That's all done now, of course. And thank fuck,Quote:
Originally posted by Fleagle the Guitarist:
Shut up and get editing!
hey. There'll be a strong current in the river
Bacchus tonight.
Good luck with the release party on Monday.
Am sorting out a mySpaz site over the weekend -
I'll stick the videos up there.
D.
<font color="#FF0099" size="1">[ June 09, 2006 09:24 AM: Message edited by: Deviant D ]</font>
Myspaz is good business mate. believe me. I found Mj there and Nick!
SHIT - all I found was lots of scantily clad females and crap bands, oh and a guy from Bosnia looking for a place to stay